You are here: Home > Message Boards > Parents of Schoolgoers >  Role of in-laws >Am I Overreacting?

Parents of Schoolgoers  Discussion Forum

 
Role of in-laws:Am I Overreacting?
2010-03-17
Name: panicked



I am a silent reader of this board. I have been married for 8 years. We have a six year old son and pregnant with my second child.He is from India and i am from Canada. (i know it is a big different). not an easy adjustment.

I just don´ t understand one thing why are Indian men so attached to their mothers.Just one day after i got married to my husband, we had gone to the mall. I am walking ahead and he is walking behind me with his mother. People are stopping her and telling her that, " you should let your son walk with is wife" What on earth is his problem?

When i was in India, i was washing dishes and my husband´ s mother comes into the kitchen and says, " beta, you should wash dishes like this." i told her that, " mama, i feel comfortable to wash the dishes the way that i am washing them." i told her this in a nice, polite way. What did i say that was so wrong in this? my husband´ s mother was sniffling or blowing her nose or something. Maybe for this reason, my husband´ s father thought she was crying. When my husband came back from his town where he works, his father told him what had happened. The next thing i know is i was in my room and my husband comes running to our room and asks." Did you make my mother cry?" I told him, " of course not" This happened close to a year after i got married to him. His father was doing nothing, but trying to put difference between my husband and me.It has been seven years since that has happened but it hurts so much every time i think of it.

This is not all, once he told me that if i ever stop his mother from interfering. i will NOT leave you, but i will never talk to you and i will also live in the same house. Can anyone believe that?

His mother is always telling him that a women needs to give her love and affection to her husband and then she will only get it back from. that is just garbage. Why should it always be the wife who gives her love and effection to her husband first. Should a women not get her husband´ s love and affection? I just don´ t understand why the wife has to make all the sacrifices for her husband. Then men should also make sacrifices for his wife. I mean husband and wife are supposed to be equal in a marriage. Right???

She also says that in order for a women to be happy in a married life, she must leave her family and move on and start a new family. What makes her think that if men don´ t leave their families, then he will have a happy, married life? That is just garbage that she is saying. She is a hypocrite. If woman are expected to leave their families after marriage, then so should men. Why should poor women leave their families while men get to cling onto their families.

I am having my baby in May. My husband is planning to call his parents here for the delivery. i really don´ t want them here. i cannot tolerate them. My 6 year old son is really thin. and my husband´ s mother blames me for him being thin. She says i didn´ t eat " punjari" when i was nursing him. Oh god! she is so ignorant! She does not realize that all punjari does is make a person fat. What about that other weight i gained during my pregnancy that i need to loose? Are there not other healthy foods that i can eat to help my baby gain weight while i am nursing him? She is so ignorant that she does not realize that when a child is fat or thin, it also matters on the child´ s genes. both me and my husband are very thin, so it does run in the genes.

i took my son to the doctor and i asked him that my son is under weight and how can i get him to gain weight? My son´ s doctor literally started laughing at me. he told me that, " your son is not underweight, he is a perfect healthy baby boy." when my son was born, he was close to 7 lbs.

now i am having a baby girl. There is a ritual of feeding the baby honey.Since his parents will be here, he wants his mother to feed my daughter the honey. I do not want that!!! I cannot stand his mother. Even before
deciding this, my husband should have enough respect for his wife to at least ask me if it is OK that he let his mother feed my baby honey. He tells me that he thought this was already obvious to me. I don´ t get it! how was this suppose to be obvious to me? Why does these Indian men treat their wives with some respect of discussing things with their wife.

One thing for sure is that his mother is always saying that he/my husband is her son. I gave him birth and so and so. A mother has the most right on her child. The baby stayed in his/her mother´ s tummy for nine months. It is the mother who went through all the pain to bring her baby in this world, so obviously she should have the most right. Then, this also should go for me right? She is such a hypocrite and full of double standards!

One thing i know for sure is that every child has love and respect for his parents and by all means he/she should. But when he gets married and brings home a wife, he should not expect from her that what feelings he has for his parents, that she should also have the same feelings. That is just not possible! That is unrealistic and irrational. i also don´ t think that it should be forced on girls to realize that her husband´ s parents raised him with such pain and hardships. do men realize that the girl´ s parents went through so much to raise their daughter and your wife? Her parents went through the same pain. Why should women realize it!

My husband´ s side are vegetarians. My husband´ s mother is always telling him NOT to feed my son non vegetarian food even though my son is here and they are in India. oh my god! it is inevitable for him to not eat non veg. when he is being raised in the states. He is going to want to eat it after he sees other children eating non veg.He is my son, not hers! This is non of her business! the more she gets after us of not feeding my son non veg., the more i want to feed it to him. There are times when i take my son out and feed him some chicken. The more she says to her son to not feed my son non veg., the more i get provoked to feed my son non veg. food. His dad does not know about it.Tell me folks am i being immature or doing something wrong?

I bought some clothes for my daughter. He is showing the clothes to his mother on the web cam. like why? what is his problem? what is the need to show his mother? is there anything between me and my husband that only me and him know. Every itty bitty thing , he has to tell his mother. His mother asks him everyday what did i cook for dinner. it is so annoying!

My husband´ s brother lives in Australia. He has been there for the past four years. He has never thought even once to call his parents down there to Australia. He is not even married and does not have a family to raise while on the other hand, my husband is married and has one son and is expecting his second child. they come here and spend so much of his money. They don´ t think even once that we are spending our sons money which he has worked hard to earn.

They say they are coming here for the delivery. On top of that, he says to them, " all the stuff you need to get from here, i will get for you." They also plan to go out on holidays, I mean out of the state. I don´ t understand if they are coming here for the delivery, then why are they talking about shopping and going out on holidays?
if they are coming here, then they should spend their whole time here on the delivery or the baby?
I can´ t believe his mom even has the nerves to ask her son if he is going to take them anywhere.
i just don´ t understand if they are coming here to spend their sons money. They should not say we are coming their for the delivery and taking care of me. This is just an excuse!!

Another thing that is just irritating me is that my husband´ s younger brother is engaged and the girl is in India. I am sure without a shadow of a doubt, she will think that i am here in U.S and i should take something for my to be Daughter in law. I really don´ t mind sending her anything. The only thing that bothers me is that she is going to use all my husband´ s money to buy her something and then on top of it, she is going to tell her to be daughter in law that she bought it for her. If her daughter in law sends something for me or my children, then i don´ t mind even to send something for her. I mean i am going to have my baby in may, the least she can do is send something for my baby girl? Should she not send something or am i just overreacting?

I thought that a parents love should be UN conditional and parents should not expect anything in return but not in my husband´ s case. My husband´ s parents are selfish. i know one thing for sure that when my children grow up, i am not going to expect even a single penny from them.
Why don´ t the parents think that when we spend our sons money, what will his wife think? Why don´ t they think that we are spending our son´ s money which he has worked hard to earn?. i would never do that to my son.

One thing i don´ t understand is that they have a problem with the clothes i wear. For god´ s sake, i was raised outside of India. when i was there in India, i use to wear clothes that pretty much covered my whole body like suits and jeans. Now when they come here, can they not understand that the clothes that i wear are of today´ s fashion? I should wear clothes according to the fashion here in US And they need to broaden their horizons on the country they have come to visit. They are such ignorant people!!! Can´ t they change and adapt to what goes on here? why do i have to change myself just for those people? They can´ t even change!


one thing i know for sure is that any girl that is married to a guy in India and he is NOT a Mama´ s boy, that girl is the most luckiest girl in the world.

i am so sorry this is long but someone tell me if i am wrong?
Subscribe to this conversation Reply Anonymously

 

2012-07-28
#1
Anonymous Name: Silvina
Subject:  indian husband / parents in law



Hi girl, I read your post from 2010, not sure if you are still married to the indian guy (i hope you are) but I felt very reflected in EVERY SINGLE word you say because I' m from Argentina, I live in the US with my husband who is from India (Punjab) and have EXACTLY the same issues as you with my mother is law. Hate is a very strong word that I never felt in my life... but I swear that I HATE that woman above the whole world and reasonable possibilities! I' m pregnant right now with my second and have had the very worst pregnancy ever because my husband is such a mama' s boy, we ONLY fight for her and nothing else than her, she' s the most horrible human being I' ve ever met... well, too much info, but I' d love to talk to you if you are interested since we are going through the same issues, we might be able to help each other... good luck, I hope you respond to me.
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2010-04-05
#2
Anonymous Name: G
Subject:  u r not overreacting



Hi Panicked. You have some real issues going on with you..and I' ll comment on one of these..the honey thing..Don' t give it much thought, it is just a stupid custom of an ignorant society which means absolutely nothing. So focus your energies on the real issues. Also, I think you' re running a big risk by feeding your son non-veg and not telling your husband about it. In a bad scenario it can give your MIL a lot of ammunition against you..so I' ll suggest you tell your husband. Also, I think someone else mentioned..please be happy during your pregnancy..You have so many good things going for you, don' t worry too much...imagine how much better off you are than if you were living with them in India !! All the best to you and the little one ..
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2010-03-21
#3
Anonymous Name: lakshmi
Subject:  Hi Panicked



Sorry to tell u that your husband is still a mamas boy ..it is bit difficult to come out of mom untill she dies.. i faced similar things and gave up..
try to give back answers to your mother in law and you also start crying (act as how she is doing) and hope things will be sorted out.
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2010-03-18
#4
Anonymous Name: panicked
Subject:  a scared mom



When they came here a couple of years ago, they had a problem if i took my son swimming. like for Heavens sake! I have my son in the water. i am watching him. When i come back home, she is telling me \" you will regret this.\" like am i stuppid, i do not know how to handle my son when he is in the water. All they want is control over me. For god' s sake i am in my late twenties. i am old enough to think what is good or bad for my son.
Unfortunately, thier tickets are already booked. They are coming in middle of may. I am having panick attacks. oh god! someone help me!

last time when they were here and my son was not listening to my husband' s mother, and she turns around and says to him, \" i don' t know who is putting you against me, whose genes are in you?\" She said this infront of me. She said this for me. She said this so i would feel bad. How can i get that same lady to feed my newborn baby girl honey? How can she even imagine that i would let her feed my daughter honey?

On top of that, last time they were here his dad saw me talking to my husband' s friends and says, \" tum to uske saath baathe bhi kari thi\" (Sorry i dont know how to spell in hindi. i am doing the best i can.)he was indirectly implieing that i am having an affair with my husband' s friend. Such low and cheap thinking.

I just don' t have the courage and strength to go through this again,

yesterday, my husband is telling me that mama is bringing cloth diapers for the baby. She is also bringing night suits for our son. I don' t know what the hell he is trying to do. Is he trying to tell me how good his mother is? I don' t want to hear it!

When i got married to my husband, my mom had given me some golden bracelets. I also got some golden bracelets from my husband' s side. Now, after so many years of marriage, she is telling my husband, that we will break these bracelets and make new new ones. She doesn' t even bother to realize that the bracelets from my mom' s side are not hers. and the ones that she gave me are mine and it is none of her business to order me around of breaking them and giving them away. My husband is just sitting there and listening to her.

I' m gonna have such a hard time when they are here. I don' t know if i can keep my mental balance.
I have just told myself that all i can do is keep my distance from them.
If they say anything to irritate me, i am not going to keep my mouth shut, i am going to scream. i don' t have the patience anymore! And also after i give birth to my baby girl. there is a chance i maybe i have post partum depression, and my hormones will be everywhere. If they say the slightest thing to me, i will not be able to keep myself back.

Last time they were here, my husband told me that they are guests here and so and so. Well, if they are guest here, then they should stay in their limits. Right?

One thing for sure is that when they come here, I have decided that i am going to do everything by myself and not depend on my husband' s mother cause i know very well how much she will help me.
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2010-03-23
#5
Anonymous Name: a bit panicked yet
Subject:  dont worry



dear panicked,as u said,watever ur son eats is your wish not ur mils,same wid me,wen i was bac in india for 20 days only dis time,my mil did everything to try n cotrol my kids,both r boys aged 6 n 3.her complaints reg.d younger on was dat he cant walk properly due to lack of good food n hence strenght, where as he is a perfectly chubby baby weighing 40lbs!!!!he cudnt keep up wid b ground in d village(stones etc.)so dat was a problem.he stopped eating food over there due to distractions(too many kids around n different taste)n i was mature enough not to compell him to eat wen he wasnt interesetd.i dint keep my kids to me over there,even then i had those stares dat say,they belong to our fly.,our boy´ s boys.....etc.n all their foolish rituals,i too am quite religious but not to dat extent where it harms my kids!!!i hate dat black spot on my kids´ face to ward off evil,n she puts it purposely to irk me,think of me n my frustration!!!!sorry if i am too confusing ,coz i´ m already confused myself.u just dont worry dear,and at any cost dont allow her to control ur SON,for d timebeing forget abt her son,sorry for being sarcastic,but he´ ll come bac to u once they r gone,reg. bac answering,v dont do it purposely like them,it happens,n god will forgive us for dat.v never had any hatred towards them,they created it,isnt it?enjoy ur pregnancy,i too am expecting,this aug.,hope its a girl!!!!!
Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2010-03-19
#6
Anonymous Name: dil
Subject:  self defence



hi panicked, now u reached the stage of self defencing, now u dont require anyone advice and sympathy, you can go on. dont worry tell the direct answers to your inlaws whatever your inlaws will tell you indirectly ( if u say like that then your heart will feel happy). Even the day i started doing and answering they stoped questioning. When you are not wrong dont fear but fight. god is with you. - Bye dil good luck
Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2010-03-18
#7
Anonymous Name: DIL
Subject:  Be Happy,



First be happy during pregnency, and dont bother about your stupid inlaws, one thing you feel happy is that your inlaws is not going to be with you all the time, as there are certain inlaws like us who are suffering 365 days with such stupid restriction and without any privacy in life. We all are very unlucky to have such husbands who cannot understand the wife' s problems. If posssible convey ur husband that a women will be comfortable only with the mother but not with MIL during her delivery time. I hope that if ur husband is having some soft corner and will understand your pains and may understand it. Pls you also dont compromise in this matter.
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2010-03-17
#8
Anonymous Name: SN
Subject:  u r not over reacting



Hi Dear,
Let me tell you that u r not at all over reacting. I can understand you feelings. I wud suggest not to allow them to be with u during your delivery. I am sure they will be of no help and more of pain. Once they are with you...u can not handle the situation so prevention is better than cure..what do u say???
Regarding what your son should eat is totally your call. Dont listen to anyone and do what u feel is right.
Take proper rest and dont take stress...enjoy ur last few months of preganancy and prepare well to welcome your princess.:)
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top

All tips on Parents of Schoolgoers
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
Am I Overreacting?


Subscribe to this conversation! All tips on Parents of Schoolgoers
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
Am I Overreacting?


Subscribe to this conversation! All tips on Parents of Schoolgoers
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
Am I Overreacting?

Thanks for subscribing
You are already a member, please login to subscribe

------ OR ------

Expecting Parents
Parents of Babies
Last 7 Posts of this Board
How to deal with this?
I feel that my husbands parents are using their son. My husband is from India and I am from the USA. He obtained his greencard and citizenship through me after coming here. He is a physician and obtained his residency training. I worked to earn for our family for two years until he got his job. Then he applied for his parents to visit us on a visiting visa. We were both wo... - Tina Shah [View Message]
RE:self centered inlaws
I agree they have completely double standards as I recently found out. I saw my husbands childhood photos when he was young. His parents claim they sacrificed everything for their kids and lived poor and behave like martyr parents. Got treated as free domestic servant. But the photos showed them dressed like Bollywood stars with watches and jewellery enjoying their life. O... - Tina [View Message]
RE:self centered inlaws
Karma has no menu. You get served what you deserve. ... - Tina [View Message]
RE:Jadu on food?
Hi , I am facing the same thing.. I married my husband and we are not only from different caste but also different country. My in-laws are so nice to me on face but I can sense the jealousy and that inferiority majorly in my mother in law and my sister in law.. I never had such doubts but I experienced pain sadness , depression while they use to be nice .. and it was confu... - Noname [View Message]
RE:Mother-in-law spoiling my child
hello kajal,
you think that excess sugar given to him by your mother in law, and thats why you are worried about your son, so dont take stress of this thing, your son is little now, after some years, he will stop eating sugar by selfly.... - nandita [View Message]
RE:Mother-in-law spoiling my child
hello kajal,
if you are dont like your mother in law behaviour then tell her on face, that you dont whenever she gave sugar to her son, so she may be stop giving sugar to him, and your porblem will be sort out.... - kamna [View Message]
RE:Mother-in-law spoiling my child
hello kajal,
if you are rudely talking with her, then this is not way to talking with your mother in law, you tell her in polite way, your son is her grand son, so she never think about his bad effects.... - ruchita [View Message]

Home | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Comments or Suggestions | Indiaparenting News Articles | Contact Us | Advertise with Us | RSS
Copyright © 1999 - 2022 India Parenting Pvt. Ltd.