You are here: Home > Message Boards > Relationships >  Working Mother >Are we doing the right thing

Relationships  Discussion Forum

 
Working Mother:Are we doing the right thing
2008-04-16
Name: Swati



Hi,

Just feel like sharing my story with you -

My son is 3 years and goes to daycare. I used to think that I' m managing well and everything is fine
until I made a trip to my place.

I could clearly make out the difference between other kids and my son.
He is not attached to me at all. He happily goes to anyone who shows chocolates or
promise to take him to garden.
Not bothered about my or hubby' s presence, not willing to come with us even if we ask him to take him out
to have fun.
But very happy all the time because every morning after taking bath he does not have to go to school.


After coming, he is not happy in his daycare and wants to be at home. I know soon he' ll get adjusted
to the daycare and everything will be fine again.

But this trip made me realize that I' m not giving him a normal childhood that I got as a kid.
I' m not sure about the impact of my work life on him in the long run.

A settled, secured childhood really helped me to grow up as a confident woman.
I knew that my mother would be waiting for me to listen my school stories.
But my son won' t be getting the same.

I know that if I quit my job, I will regret on my decision later.
But am I being selfish by not giving the most deserved thing to a child and continuing my career just for few more bucks, avoid boarness and many more factors.

I know its hard to leave a job when you have put 5-6 years or more of your life but a good childhood is equally important for a kid.

Just wanted to know whether few other moms also think in the same manner or we all are leading the same life because others are also doing the same.
Are we really doing it for the sake of our kids or for ourselevs and enjoy being tagged as busy working moms.
Subscribe to this conversation Reply Anonymously

 

2008-04-23
#1
Anonymous Name: rekha
Subject:  excuse me



hello,

take ur words back..if we are working its for our kids where we need to give them good life..whats the use of saying I LOVE YOU sit in front of them and dont give quality life for them..of course all are humans and we need to live for ourself as well and i dont think its called mean..everybody have their own perspective , if u have money oen can manage staying back or doing whatever they want in life..and just say one is house wife they spend max time on tv,phones, household chores and again kids take back space..please read this as generalized message and nobody is intended..
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2008-04-22
#2
Anonymous Name: hello
Subject:  Depends on person..



Hello,

i have seen all post here and came to know onething.
All who are working is less bothered about their kid. They are satisfied with spending 2hrs in the morning and 4hrs in the evening.
i am not married and pregnant. My mom and dad is still working. I know how much i missed my mom when i need her in my childhood age. Today i' m successfull in my life. Holding an engineering degree and if i want, i cat get 5 digit salary easily. As Saheli said, my parents are successful by going to job and i also grown up and successfull in my life.
But Only, i know what i missed in my life. I cannot get that life back.
What i decided is, not going to job after graduation and i am doing that. Now my husband is supportive and we are leading happy life and expecting our baby this year. I will live for my kid. I didnt lost anything by not going to work but i have lot of time for my own life and lot of time to spend with my husband and will have lot of time for my kid.
From my point of view, those how are working (both parents), they are selfish on their own life and compromising on their kid' s life.
Money is important and not everything.
You life is important but your little angel' s life is more important because they know only their parents. They will compromise anything for their parents..so parents please dont be selfish...
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2008-04-23
#3
Anonymous Name: reshmi
Subject:  to swati



i know its hard on my part.now we are living on single income.its hard.i mean the rent of home,the commodities.even to buy 1kg of veggies for a week it cost so high,fish everything.waterbill is worst.this gulf country and the price of petrol is lower than water but we cant live on that.
i dont want my hubby to tak all the pain,he´ s stressing himself too much.i know mama didnt sent us to creche wen we were young.diff times i would say.there was grandma,less need of secondary income.she started working wen i was 9 and bro-3.now my kid cannont be with grandma since my mum is still working.my inlaws are too told to tak care of baby.
if iam working its for my kid. i want my kid to enjoy all the luxuries which i havent(cant say i missed out anything coz we were brought up like taht).without money we wont be treated good by others.i cant imagine the day iam like taht.i feel so sad now ,i cant decide.personally i have know kids(my best friend) who were sent to creche as young as 1 month and grown up into strong adults.not at all dependent on anyone.
so i hope whatever decision i tak ,hopefully that will be good for my family.
Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2008-04-23
#4
Anonymous Name: swati
Subject:  Thats what I wanted to know



Thanks Hello for sharing your thoughts.
Thats exactly what I was looking for, how a kid will feel after growing up?

Whenever I look back and think about my childhood I feel so good.. and thanks my mom for being around me when I needed her most.

Same thing I want for my son also.Thats the reason I decided to devote my max time to him.

rekha,
Whatever I shared here are just my thoughts...please don´ t take it personally.

Other than my kid I´ m also concerned for our society because I´ m seeing these things around me..that might not be the same case with you.

What my intentions are - If I can survive on one salary, I should give 7-8 years of my life to my children. Else we all know we have to work to feed our kids.

Please do not take it personally. But again I´ m seeing one post here by Reshmi, a 5 months pregnant woman..waiting to go back to work when the kid will be 6 months.
I can understand her worries about her career but a 6 months child cannot.
She is not much worried about her kid because daycare options is always open for her kid but her job might not be same.

Where our society is heading? Personally I feel this is not right and just want to know what others feel.
Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2008-04-22
#5
Anonymous Name: hello
Subject:  Mistake in a sentense...



Please read this as
" i am now married and pregnant" . it was a typo
Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2008-04-21
#6
Anonymous Name: reshmi
Subject:  hai everyone.i feel so bad



well i havent reachd any of ur stages.iam 5 months preg now.i had to forcefully and sadly quit work owing to bed rest.but sitting at hom is sick and gettin me depressed.i feel left out
so even aftr teh kid i wish and plan to get bac wen baby is 6-7 months old.is it too early?.around me i have seeen moms sendings kids to daycare at 1 month itself.financially we arent well off.we hav to see both sides ya.kid,money both are imp for me.
can anyone suggest me someting?iam working in medical field.iam a clinical pharmacist and previously i worked in a company.hospital work might envolve shifts.so shd i go bac to company where i was med secretary with flexible timings or go for hospitals, where my career ,my growth and more money is?i have no idea abt wat iam doin.
iam turning 24 wen baby comes(due in aug).is it too late to start career.i mean so competitive world here
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2008-04-21
#7
Anonymous Name: swati
Subject:  Question is diffrent



Thanks Saheli for analyzing my problem and replying back.

I know everything will be normal again with my kid and he will be adjusted to daycare and so on.
But whole idea to sharing my thought is - Is this right thing I' m doing to my kid?

I joined workforce again because I was bugged up seating at home, felt useless and all my friends were working either putting their kids to daycare or maid.
There was no financial pressure on me, we could manage in single earning but definitely not afford a great lifestyle.
But those were my problems, my poor kid is still not aware of all these that since his mom is not good in managing home hence she is leaving him somewhere for whole day.

My kid just wants his mom to be with him for his initial years.
Being a mother you know that its a undebatable topic.

Amazing part here is, many of us are not working for only money, that somehow can be justified since a kid needs food more than his mother. But I' m sure while typing it, that many of us can very well manage without working also.
We all are working because we do not want to sit idle at home, cannot live with in-laws, do not want to leave career, etc...
Believe me, I' ve come across many women who are continuing work due to above reasons.
They feel bad at times but still continuing to do same.

Isn' t it a selfish decision? Or its a peer pressure that if she can work I can also do?


Again its just a question on our society where husbands support their wives to leave kid to daycare but go to work and get money. Daycare numbers have increased like anyhting in last few years and still getting increased day by day.Women are giving priority to their career on their kids.

I can understand this for a woman who has given many years to her profession but now a normal graduate woman also wants to work and leave her 1-2 years old kid to daycare rather than waiting for few more years till the child grow.
I can tell this because I myself is a role model to many women in my neighbourhood.If those women will choose work over their kids, few more kids will endup in daycares.

Again - Is this right thing we are doing to our kids?

It might touch some of you, but just felt like sharing my thoughts.
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2008-04-20
#8
Anonymous Name: Saheli
Subject:  re:



I could pick up two focus points from your post. One, the practical problems you are seeing w.r.t your child and two, what overall is a right thing to do for a woman like you and me.

There cannot be a generic answer to these questions. Such cases need an individual analysis and conclusion too. What has worked for me does not necessarily mean it' ll work for you.

Allow me to focus on the first point for now.

I am assuming that it was that one incident that \" helped you understand what was going on and made you think thru to take a decision\" . If I were to frame this sentence in quotes in other way, I can say \" one incident and you are jumping to conclusion that things are so sad and thinking of extreme step like having a job or not\" .

Undoubtedly, the best thing for a child is to have the mother full time at home. But lets keep that point aside for now.

Have you tried working on the problem? There are women who are balancing the whole thing and the kids too are doing good. And I can quote examples of such success stories not just from our generation but a couple of previous generations where mothers have been working.

Regarding your child - It could be that you guys are not giving him enough time / not giving him quality time / daycare isnt suiting him may be a maid will work / some such problem. Do you spend your mornings and evenings in kitchen/whatever rather than the kid?

I hv seen kids not attached to their moms who are housewives. I wouldnt agree that being a working woman is solely resp for this.

What I want to suggest is -
Try and work on the problems you are seeing in your child. Figure out the gaps and try n fill them up. Give him quality and quantity time - both of u. Make sure he goes to a suitable school/daycare where they give attention personally.

Try and balance out the whole deal once again by making the moves at places required. And if still things do not work, you always hv the option of a part time job, or being a complete housewife.

If you think you have already made all attempts to get the child' s problem resolved, then you probably already have your answers.
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2008-04-19
#9
Anonymous Name: manju
Subject:  Quiting the job



s, i also had same feeling. My son is 5 yrs now, i have resigned last week only.
i have also found lot of differences with other kids. He is very active and intellegent, but he is not doing common things which other same age kids does. I think chils shall get all the things which is required.

it was very difficult for me to resign, but after a long conflict, i have resigned.
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2008-04-21
#10
Anonymous Name: rekha
Subject:  how long?



Swati / Pritee / Manju,

How long you guys plan to quit and stay back at home..probably after 6 yrs kids will be atleast 7 - 8 hours outside(i mean school) and dont u think once can be back in the mean time or 1-2 hours difference should ideally not matter..? I understand once the kid is back mom need to feed, make them study etc..phir bhi i guess one can work and manage all these..not sure at this point whether this makes sense or not as my kid is 3 yrs not come to this stage..any one in this phase can reply better..
Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2008-04-20
#11
Anonymous Name: swati
Subject:  same here



After a lot of discussions with hubby, I´ ve finally decided no more daycare for my son.
I´ ll try for part-time in my current org, else good-bye to working life.

After all this is the time kids should enjoy being at home and spend evenings in the garden rather than waiting for their mothers in packed daycare centers.
I do not want to take his wonderful days to fulfill my future needs and regret later.
Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2008-04-17
#12
Anonymous Name: pritee
Subject:  who can say wats the right thing ?



hi swati & rekha,

i have a 1.5 year old child & started working wen he was 1 year old. took a long break for pregancy & child care. its been only 6 months that i joined work.

i agree with wat u girls say ... m leading \" the difficult life\" , juggling between work & home & away from my child !!! & all the after effects ....

MIL & a maid took care of him. but this week my maid ran away & right now my MIL is having a tough time managing alone. but tell me how much time can i stretch .... force-fully i plan to quit & guess wat i might be the unlucky one to find a maid once i QUIT !

dont know if m right or wrong ....


rekha: in your case u r lucky that ur husband became a business man.
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2008-04-17
#13
Anonymous Name: Rekha
Subject:   not really sure



Pritee,

I know my daughter is properly taken care but again there are few clashes b/n my hubby and me as men is at home and I have become primary bread earner and is income is almost zero. But even then really happy that my baby is taken good care and am very sure he takes better care and as more patience then me :)..being a mom is toughtest role i am playing..

thanks,
rekha
Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2008-04-16
#14
Anonymous Name: Rekha
Subject:  Really True



Swati,

I completely agree with you. I am working in IT and when my baby used to go to maid saying maa , I started hating what I was doing like going out to work.. Luckily that maid went out and we never had anyone to look after baby my hubby quit his job and started a business , so one of us are always with my baby so she gets both of us. I know money,coporate ladder everything is important , after all we are earning for kids if they are not happy whats the use of such money.

My 2 cents worth on ur thoughts.!!

Rekha

Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top

All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
Are we doing the right thing


Subscribe to this conversation! All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
Are we doing the right thing


Subscribe to this conversation! All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
Are we doing the right thing

Thanks for subscribing
You are already a member, please login to subscribe

------ OR ------

Expecting Parents
Parents of Babies
Last 7 Posts of this Board
Healthcare
I am nutrition expert. If anyone faces any problems related health. Be in touch.. My expertise is in ganotherapy... Natural products.. I do not sell anything.. I will advise.. ... - Dipak Hadawale [View Message]
RE:Working Mother
plsssssssssssssssss reply to the above msg
can nybody advice me .
thanks
... - sumedha [View Message]
RE:Working Mother
pls reply...
pls advice... - sumedha [View Message]
depressed. pls advice
Pls advice.
I am a mother of 4 years old son and I am working woman. I usually left home by 9 in morning and reach by 8 in evening.
I usually get quality time with my son on Sundays/holidays. But then as i reach home by 8 eve, I realy work hard to finish the work and food by 10 or 10:30 to make love with my son coz i love him very much after my husband.
N... - Sumedha Dogra [View Message]
RE:Working Mother
Pls advice.
I am a mother of 4 years old son and I am working woman. I usually left home by 9 in morning and reach by 8 in evening.
I usually get quality time with my son on Sundays/holidays. But then as i reach home by 8 eve, I realy work hard to finish the work and food by 10 or 10:30 to make love with my son coz i love him very much after my husband.
N... - sumedha [View Message]
RE:yes i have a creche at my home
Hi Neetu where is your day care in noida
... - Upasana [View Message]
RE:
hello mother,
now a days every women try to independent, and live life on her terms and conditions so its great thing itself.... - nisha [View Message]