im a new member ,guess wot im also facing problems with my inlaws, i became mum, thz april and things just seem to be getting worst with my il. im married 2 an indian, but im not indian. infact our cultures r completely different, but eversince ive been with my husband , ive been trying 2 understand him and learn a bit of his culture. but now that we have a child , things have to change, coz im christian, u to be frank me and my husband decided that we were not going to do anything frm our culture, coz we just dont want our kids to be confused. we decided , because we have a mixed marriage , we would only do the main festival on his side and on my side as well.but the thing is tha my SIL she always come and say that she has to do things with her brother coz i dnt know wot festival. n at the end when i tell my husband that thz isnt wot we agreed for, he says that its hisculture etc.. i hope u guys understand me, being a mother now i cant put my culture before wots best for my child. n its obvious that if my husband does his things, me as well ill want to do my things. n it wud be pulling a string on both side and my child will be stuck in middle. i just dont know what to do, coz for my husband its always his sister' s opinon which is important. but i cant do that i have to put my child first. its nothing to do with culture or religion but im just trying to do wots best for my daughter. plz i need some help coz i went through so much with my inlaws that now ive realise that everytime they do things in a way that my husband cant see anything. and because of them everytime we fight, and i just feel like leaving. my husband says that i dnt understand his culture, every indian person is like that. PLZ IVE NO INTENTION OF OFFENDING ANYONE. I JUST WANT TO KNOW WHETHER IS USING HIS COVER AS AN EXCUSE. just like when his mum cum to visit us, she' s always entering my room, no matter if im sleeping , i just dont have a privacy, and here also my husband wud say its his culture, when my baby was born we were told by the doc that my baby might have an handicap, but it wasnt sure, we told only my MIL and we said until we r sure we not gona tell anyone, but the very next day everyone, of my SIL family knew about it, and here also my husband wud say its his culture. i dnt know anymore. plz help im i wrong???
Subscribe to this conversation
Reply Anonymously
im a new member ,guess wot im also facing problems with my inlaws, i became mum, thz april and things just seem to be getting worst with my il. im married 2 an indian, but im not indian. infact our cultures r completely different, but eversince ive been with my husband , ive been trying 2 understand him and learn a bit of his culture. but now that we have a child , things have to change, coz im christian, u to be frank me and my husband decided that we were not going to do anything frm our culture, coz we just dont want our kids to be confused. we decided , because we have a mixed marriage , we would only do the main festival on his side and on my side as well.but the thing is tha my SIL she always come and say that she has to do things with her brother coz i dnt know wot festival. n at the end when i tell my husband that thz isnt wot we agreed for, he says that its hisculture etc.. i hope u guys understand me, being a mother now i cant put my culture before wots best for my child. n its obvious that if my husband does his things, me as well ill want to do my things. n it wud be pulling a string on both side and my child will be stuck in middle. i just dont know what to do, coz for my husband its always his sister' s opinon which is important. but i cant do that i have to put my child first. its nothing to do with culture or religion but im just trying to do wots best for my daughter. plz i need some help coz i went through so much with my inlaws that now ive realise that everytime they do things in a way that my husband cant see anything. and because of them everytime we fight, and i just feel like leaving. my husband says that i dnt understand his culture, every indian person is like that. PLZ IVE NO INTENTION OF OFFENDING ANYONE. I JUST WANT TO KNOW WHETHER IS USING HIS COVER AS AN EXCUSE. just like when his mum cum to visit us, she' s always entering my room, no matter if im sleeping , i just dont have a privacy, and here also my husband wud say its his culture, when my baby was born we were told by the doc that my baby might have an handicap, but it wasnt sure, we told only my MIL and we said until we r sure we not gona tell anyone, but the very next day everyone, of my SIL family knew about it, and here also my husband wud say its his culture. i dnt know anymore. plz help im i wrong???
Gayu replied. I completely understand what you are going thru.My case is no different from Mel' s ,I am also a christian who is married to a hindu,and I am an Indian,but the cultural and traditional differences are huge even between our families.
But I do agree that I am not an alien to my hubby' s religion or traditions.
In our case we decided right from the beginning that our kid would follow my hubby' s religion but just like Mel also follow the important religious festivals from my side.
It is funny though that in india (am not sure how it is in the other parts of the world)the girl' s in-laws do try and make things difficult for the wife.And when a child is born the wife becomes an even bigger problem for the in-laws.
Its also true that in-laws do barge into the room but thats how they are I guess.It may be just that they r trying to be territorial as in, its their son' s room not the wife' s.The wife does not belong anywhere in the family.
But I think in your case you may need to have a heart to heart talk with your hubby regarding this issue.And maybe try to reason with him regarding the issues that are bothering you.Most of the women in india do have to compromise a lot.And there is a tiny little fact of the matter when a child is born,families esp inter-religious ones do get divided when it comes down to these issues as to which religion the kid should follow.Most importantly in-laws will try to create probs b/w you guys.So hope you can stay above their mean ways and,
I hope both of you are able to sort out these issues for the sake of your child and for both of you.
Mel replied. Hi Ana. I' m an Indian. I am also a Christian, married to a Hindu. And I faced quite a lot of issues when it came to adjusting with my ILs.
I don' t agree with the barging into your room logic. It is NOT our culture. But, Hindus give a lot of respect to their elders... even to the point of being uncomfortable.
About your child, it is between you and your husband about how you want to bring him / her up. Before we got married, my husband and I decided to raise our child as a Hindu. But, we also agreed that we would celebrate all festivals, go to both places of worship, etc. This way, there' s no confusion about his identity and religion, and at the same time, he will be more tolerant and understanding of all religions.
This has worked well for us. Celebrate all festivals nicely. Let your child be exposed to it. Ignore the MIL and SIL as much as you can.
Sometimes, I can' t bear the way my husband lets my ILs sit on his head, even when he knows they are wrong he says he feels guilty... as if HE is doing something wrong by not tolerating their overbearing behaviour.
Mana K. replied. dear ana
if u belong to western world then living with indian customs specially in joint family will sure be a cultural shock to u. to answer your questions , yes its very common in india that mil needs no permission to enter dil' s room. mil comes n goes as please though this is not the case with all. some mil do respect privacy but majority thinks that they do not need dil' s approval before barging in. in joint familes one of the major disadvantage is lack of privacy. now as far as spreading the news about your baby' s chances of having handicap is NOT related to indian culture , its just lack of social grace and inability to guard something private/emotional. ur mil / sil did bad by making it spread when u did not want it to and when it was not confirmed.
2008-10-21
#1
Name: Gayu Subject: Hey ana!!
I completely understand what you are going thru.My case is no different from Mel' s ,I am also a christian who is married to a hindu,and I am an Indian,but the cultural and traditional differences are huge even between our families.
But I do agree that I am not an alien to my hubby' s religion or traditions.
In our case we decided right from the beginning that our kid would follow my hubby' s religion but just like Mel also follow the important religious festivals from my side.
It is funny though that in india (am not sure how it is in the other parts of the world)the girl' s in-laws do try and make things difficult for the wife.And when a child is born the wife becomes an even bigger problem for the in-laws.
Its also true that in-laws do barge into the room but thats how they are I guess.It may be just that they r trying to be territorial as in, its their son' s room not the wife' s.The wife does not belong anywhere in the family.
But I think in your case you may need to have a heart to heart talk with your hubby regarding this issue.And maybe try to reason with him regarding the issues that are bothering you.Most of the women in india do have to compromise a lot.And there is a tiny little fact of the matter when a child is born,families esp inter-religious ones do get divided when it comes down to these issues as to which religion the kid should follow.Most importantly in-laws will try to create probs b/w you guys.So hope you can stay above their mean ways and,
I hope both of you are able to sort out these issues for the sake of your child and for both of you.
2008-10-22
#2
Name: ana Subject: hi gaya
well i understand that my hus culture is different, but u see what bothers me more is that, when we got married we accepted each other for what we r, and also that we got married without the consent of my parents coz they didnt agree, but we love each other. and from very beginning we agreed that we not gona impose anythg on our kids, etc... we already had decided abt thz issue. but now his family is reacting like i should be following on my hus culture, and my hus is doing the same thing, just because my SIL has put that in his mind. it hurts because between us there was never any culture issue etc.. and i believe that when u get married, u becoming the other half of ur hus, thus we should be treating each other equally. im lost to be frank, i know that my hus loves me, but i start to wonder whether i did mistake marrying someone of a different background.
2008-10-22
#3
Name: ana Subject: hi gaya
well i understand that my hus culture is different, but u see what bothers me more is that, when we got married we accepted each other for what we r, and also that we got married without the consent of my parents coz they didnt agree, but we love each other. and from very beginning we agreed that we not gona impose anythg on our kids, etc... we already had decided abt thz issue. but now his family is reacting like i should be following on my hus culture, and my hus is doing the same thing, just because my SIL has put that in his mind. it hurts because between us there was never any culture issue etc.. and i believe that when u get married, u becoming the other half of ur hus, thus we should be treating each other equally. im lost to be frank, i know that my hus loves me, but i start to wonder whether i did mistake marrying someone of a different background.
2008-10-19
#4
Name: Mel Subject: Hi
Hi Ana. I' m an Indian. I am also a Christian, married to a Hindu. And I faced quite a lot of issues when it came to adjusting with my ILs.
I don' t agree with the barging into your room logic. It is NOT our culture. But, Hindus give a lot of respect to their elders... even to the point of being uncomfortable.
About your child, it is between you and your husband about how you want to bring him / her up. Before we got married, my husband and I decided to raise our child as a Hindu. But, we also agreed that we would celebrate all festivals, go to both places of worship, etc. This way, there' s no confusion about his identity and religion, and at the same time, he will be more tolerant and understanding of all religions.
This has worked well for us. Celebrate all festivals nicely. Let your child be exposed to it. Ignore the MIL and SIL as much as you can.
Sometimes, I can' t bear the way my husband lets my ILs sit on his head, even when he knows they are wrong he says he feels guilty... as if HE is doing something wrong by not tolerating their overbearing behaviour.
2008-10-20
#5
Name: ana Subject: hi mel
thx 4 ur advice, u see i myself my parents were of different cultures etc. but they try 2 teach us both cultures but at the end it didnt work and it was us kids who got confused. until the day that my parents decided that we were gona follow only 1 culture and when we r big enough we cud choose what we want to follow . and this is what i dnt want 2 do, like we decided before that we were gona celebrate the main festival on my hus side and on my side. and when my daughter gets big then she will see what likes and she will do it. but the thing is since she was born, my ILS are imposing for my child to be following everything on their side etc, and they telling me that girl r supposed to follow the culure of their husband. but what they dnt want to understand is that im not an indian girl and i cant live as such. as i said to my hus , when we got married we accepted each other as we were , but now he´ s imposing things on me. and i feel like may he would ve been happier if he had got married to an indian girl. i didnt know that i wud be facing so much problems by getting married. even to buy a dinning table, his sister has to choose which 1 to buy for my house. my opinion doesnt count.
2008-10-18
#6
Name: Mana K. Subject: hi
dear ana
if u belong to western world then living with indian customs specially in joint family will sure be a cultural shock to u. to answer your questions , yes its very common in india that mil needs no permission to enter dil' s room. mil comes n goes as please though this is not the case with all. some mil do respect privacy but majority thinks that they do not need dil' s approval before barging in. in joint familes one of the major disadvantage is lack of privacy. now as far as spreading the news about your baby' s chances of having handicap is NOT related to indian culture , its just lack of social grace and inability to guard something private/emotional. ur mil / sil did bad by making it spread when u did not want it to and when it was not confirmed.
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic : hi everyone
Subscribe to this conversation!
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic : hi everyone
Subscribe to this conversation!
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
Don't think too much .its common Nowdays... - Deepika [View Message]
RE:RE:sex in joint family
Wish to know one real person... - Dippy [View Message]
Arrangement with inlaws
Hi Everyone,
I am about to get married soon and I want suggestion regarding a certain living arrangement that me, my to be husband and in-laws are thinking about to maintain peace as well as be available for each other.
We are confused as to if we should live in the same house and different floors or we should stay in separate apartments in the same apartment s... - Anupama Singhal [View Message]
RE:RE:sex in joint family
One should take care. It's private. ... - Dippy [View Message]
Should a single man live with his mum in India?
I am a man in my late 40s and I have lived abroad in USA for the past two decades. I never had any interest in marrying or having kids so I never married. Recently my Dad passed away and my mother will be alone. I have made enough money to retire comfortably but because I am used to the American lifestyle I can't live in India. Recently my relatives have started saying tha... - Venkat Dabri [View Message]
RE:sex in joint family
It's very common in joint family.just ignore... - Minal [View Message]
I am Newhere
Hi all , I am newbie to this forum...hope you all feel well... - Lucamia Ava [View Message]