Hi friends pl read my problem and suggest you' ve always been a help in those very bad days.Thanks again.
Subscribe to this conversation
Reply Anonymously
Hi friends pl read my problem and suggest you' ve always been a help in those very bad days.Thanks again.
MM replied. Mine and your stories are very similar except that in your acse it MIL and in my case its FIL and SIL combination.
My SIL is a gynae, stays with my FIL in his house with her 2 children.Her husband comes over for the weekend.My FIL pays for all her expenses though hi is retired. SIL' s hubby takes even a mosquito repellent from my FIL' s house.I had stayed in that house for my delivery.She made my life hell there. She told lies to my FIL that I had asked her to leave the house etc.The outcome was she got a share in property, though she is rich from her FIL' s side. All relatives from her inlaws side come to visit her at my FILs place.
My FIL says she is a bechari, her hubby is not a nice person. My FIL also seems to be afraid of her. He will not even talk to me or my son in her presence. It is a very strange thing to say but he is jealous of me and my son i.e his grandson. How is that possible but I have experienced jealuosy at several occassios? So I have stopped going there. My FIL has build a big nursing home for SIL on a plot which he had purchased in my hubby' s name.FIL says my hubby is its owner, but I am not sure about the legal issues.
I have anothe SIL who stays in US with hubby and son. They are very rich and among the 3 siblngs the most well -off. But her hubby even has eye on the property.The scene is that except my hubby everyone wants the share in property. I do not have MIL but 2 very domination SILs and a happy go lucky hubby which is the youngest among the 3.
Any suggestions as to how I should react in this situation?
Srey replied. You' re a brave women. I hope you know that. I' ve posted my response on your other thread, so Check it out if you want. I Apologize for the late reply. I' ve been running around like a chicken with it' s head cut off. *laughting* J/K
Actually, I am pleased to see that you have people here to help you during your time of need.(like Ritika) And Yes! This is the main reason why we are here. Helping each other out. *hugs*
Ritika replied. Hi Geeta,
Try to find out if there is any other yoga class you can go to...I understand it must be difficult for you to concentrate on yoga when the very people you want to avoid land up there...incidentally, did you tell your SIL about the yoga class?
From next time, be a little aloof and don' t tell them everything that you are doing during the day.
As for your MIL, let me tell you one tip. Think of it this way - You are not here to win a popularity contest. So there is no need for you to be listening to everybody and doing what they say.
Listen to people but finally it should be you who decides what you are going to do...that includes what you do with your time.
For example, your MIL has been given a clean certificate from the doc. So when she again insists on you driving her, tell her firmly that you cannot as you are not feeling well and want to rest. Tell her to ask your SIL or take a cab.
In fact, watch yr SIL carefully. How she interacts with your MIL, what excuses she gives for doing her own thing and not following yr MIL blindly etc. You will get quite an education in learning to stand up for yourself...
People who are selfish and mean...will never appreciate you when you are all goody goody with them. The moment you start ignoring them and living your own life, they realize that they cannot take you for granted and start to appreciate you.
It is up to you to guide others on how to treat you. You can either be meek and subservient and let people walk all over you. Or decide that you are worth more and you deserve a life that is more enriching. Make your happy moments. Don' t wait for fate to bring it to you (translation, don' t think that your MIL, SIL are going to have a change of heart suddenly and will start treating you nicely). Talk to them normally but if any of them treats you badly, then just stop talking to them. Listening to them take advantage of you or ridicule you and keeping quiet would in fact be a tacit admission that their behavior is acceptable. Don' t do that in future. Stand up and speak up. You don' t need to be rude or shout/scream, but you can be firm in your tone and voice and that can be very effective.
As I said before, go out for outings with your husband and kid on the weekends. When you go to the meditation or yoga class, make friends there..go for a coffee after the class and talk about sundry stuff. Your loneliness will decrease.
One last suggestion. This is something that works for me. Have you tried any dance/aerobics class? Those are really, really fun and you feel all energized after doing it. If you have never tried it, then try it today. Put on some music and start dancing in your room. I' m sure it will relieve some of your tension instantly.
Also, don' t give guilt trips to others. Example rather than telling your husband that \" you don' t take me anywhere\" or \" you don' t do anything romantic\" , make the effort to do whatever you want to do and involve yr husband in it.
Try to ignore yr MIL and SIL and don' t give them too much importance in your life. You had a life before you met them..and you have one without them. Don' t give them so much control over you. It is not worth it.
Take care and promise to yourself that 2008 will be a happier year for you.
love,
Ritika
Ritika replied. Dear Geeta,
Your MIL and SIL love to make you miserable, don' t they. Seems as if they love to pick up a fight and then they get to shout and scream and feel wonderful about it.
How are you coping on the husband front? Are you still doing a lot of household work? Or are you getting some rest??
The thing is there is very little you can change about your MIL or SIL. I don' t know why they are behaving this way and I don' t care. What I do care about is for you not to get so upset over them.
Knowing yr SIL' s nature - that she gets upset if someone intrudes her space (she might be considering the entire 2nd flr as her personal space and did not like a servant coming up without her permission...I don' t know..am guessing here..), I would seriously not interact with her much. Send yr servant up when your husband is present in the house (so he can hear what is happening).
I don' t think there is any law about 2nd flr people owning the terrace specially since its supposed to be one house and one family.
Have you thought about moving out from this atmosphere? Frankly I do not see one positive thing for you to stay there. Your kid is not looked after by yr MIL. She goes to day care. In fact she hears you get abused by her grandmom. She sees her mother getting depressed...it must be really hard for her...
Can you talk to your husband about living separately? When there are too many vessels in a basket, there is bound to be noise. If there were few vessels, there wouldn' t be so much of drama and tension.
Lastly, try not to think about stuff like who drew on the walls or who threw things on the balcony. Focus on the bigger issues - like did I smile today, did I have a nice conversation with my hubby, did I work on my hobby today...etc etc.
As for all the stuff that gets thrown on yr balcony, just quietly go and pick it up and put it in a box in yr room. Then donate it to charity if the claimants do not apologize and claim it in 2 weeks. As for your MIL. Just stop talking to her. There is no need for you to listen to her abuse. When she starts abusing, tell her to mind her language and then walk away.
Also, plan more outings with your husband...go out on vacation more often..in fact do it every weekend so that you don' t spend it at home with yr MIL and SIL.
take care...
2008-02-05
#1
Name: MM Subject: Hello Geeta
Mine and your stories are very similar except that in your acse it MIL and in my case its FIL and SIL combination.
My SIL is a gynae, stays with my FIL in his house with her 2 children.Her husband comes over for the weekend.My FIL pays for all her expenses though hi is retired. SIL' s hubby takes even a mosquito repellent from my FIL' s house.I had stayed in that house for my delivery.She made my life hell there. She told lies to my FIL that I had asked her to leave the house etc.The outcome was she got a share in property, though she is rich from her FIL' s side. All relatives from her inlaws side come to visit her at my FILs place.
My FIL says she is a bechari, her hubby is not a nice person. My FIL also seems to be afraid of her. He will not even talk to me or my son in her presence. It is a very strange thing to say but he is jealous of me and my son i.e his grandson. How is that possible but I have experienced jealuosy at several occassios? So I have stopped going there. My FIL has build a big nursing home for SIL on a plot which he had purchased in my hubby' s name.FIL says my hubby is its owner, but I am not sure about the legal issues.
I have anothe SIL who stays in US with hubby and son. They are very rich and among the 3 siblngs the most well -off. But her hubby even has eye on the property.The scene is that except my hubby everyone wants the share in property. I do not have MIL but 2 very domination SILs and a happy go lucky hubby which is the youngest among the 3.
Any suggestions as to how I should react in this situation?
2008-02-05
#2
Name: Srey Subject: Hello Geeta.
You' re a brave women. I hope you know that. I' ve posted my response on your other thread, so Check it out if you want. I Apologize for the late reply. I' ve been running around like a chicken with it' s head cut off. *laughting* J/K
Actually, I am pleased to see that you have people here to help you during your time of need.(like Ritika) And Yes! This is the main reason why we are here. Helping each other out. *hugs*
2008-01-28
#3
Name: Ritika Subject: Re:
Hi Geeta,
Try to find out if there is any other yoga class you can go to...I understand it must be difficult for you to concentrate on yoga when the very people you want to avoid land up there...incidentally, did you tell your SIL about the yoga class?
From next time, be a little aloof and don' t tell them everything that you are doing during the day.
As for your MIL, let me tell you one tip. Think of it this way - You are not here to win a popularity contest. So there is no need for you to be listening to everybody and doing what they say.
Listen to people but finally it should be you who decides what you are going to do...that includes what you do with your time.
For example, your MIL has been given a clean certificate from the doc. So when she again insists on you driving her, tell her firmly that you cannot as you are not feeling well and want to rest. Tell her to ask your SIL or take a cab.
In fact, watch yr SIL carefully. How she interacts with your MIL, what excuses she gives for doing her own thing and not following yr MIL blindly etc. You will get quite an education in learning to stand up for yourself...
People who are selfish and mean...will never appreciate you when you are all goody goody with them. The moment you start ignoring them and living your own life, they realize that they cannot take you for granted and start to appreciate you.
It is up to you to guide others on how to treat you. You can either be meek and subservient and let people walk all over you. Or decide that you are worth more and you deserve a life that is more enriching. Make your happy moments. Don' t wait for fate to bring it to you (translation, don' t think that your MIL, SIL are going to have a change of heart suddenly and will start treating you nicely). Talk to them normally but if any of them treats you badly, then just stop talking to them. Listening to them take advantage of you or ridicule you and keeping quiet would in fact be a tacit admission that their behavior is acceptable. Don' t do that in future. Stand up and speak up. You don' t need to be rude or shout/scream, but you can be firm in your tone and voice and that can be very effective.
As I said before, go out for outings with your husband and kid on the weekends. When you go to the meditation or yoga class, make friends there..go for a coffee after the class and talk about sundry stuff. Your loneliness will decrease.
One last suggestion. This is something that works for me. Have you tried any dance/aerobics class? Those are really, really fun and you feel all energized after doing it. If you have never tried it, then try it today. Put on some music and start dancing in your room. I' m sure it will relieve some of your tension instantly.
Also, don' t give guilt trips to others. Example rather than telling your husband that \" you don' t take me anywhere\" or \" you don' t do anything romantic\" , make the effort to do whatever you want to do and involve yr husband in it.
Try to ignore yr MIL and SIL and don' t give them too much importance in your life. You had a life before you met them..and you have one without them. Don' t give them so much control over you. It is not worth it.
Take care and promise to yourself that 2008 will be a happier year for you.
love,
Ritika
2008-01-30
#4
Name: Geeta Subject: praises
Hi Ritika you really made me laugh today.Specially when I Imagined their faces doing such acts.Regarding my MIL she is trying to stick on to me saying that meri gas khatam ho gayi so I will have food with you.My daughter doesnt like it I can feel it because she(MIL) eyes on her food too.I dont know when her gas would come and when she would leave us and go.Till the time she sits with us she talks all crap all praises of my SIL,I get fed up ,I ignore and walk away then she follows me whereever I go except loo ofcourse.She keeps on asking me yeh computer pe kya karti rehti hai?Mujhe bhi computer sikha de and I just smile.Thanks again Ritika
2008-01-30
#5
Name: Ritika Subject: Re:
Dear Geeta,
So sorry to hear that you are not keeping well..but am glad to know that you are doing yoga at home...that´ s the spirit girl!! :)
Btw, your SIL sounds absolutely crazy!! I can´ t believe she actually followed you!! :) Did you let her know later on that there was no need to follow you..next time she can ask if she is so curious...he he...
Anyways, think of it that the best form of flattery is imitation...so secretly they do admire you...and try hard to reach to your level...and then hate themselves for it..and hence try to ridicule you or put you down...
Hey, this copy cat thing gave me an idea..can you tell them a list of activities (imaginary ones) that you are planning to do...and let them run about trying to also do it...:) that should be fun...
Stay warm...
love,
Ritika
2008-01-29
#6
Name: Geeta Subject: another day
Good morning Ritika,I feel good whenever I read your mails.Thanks.As the weather is cold in India at present Iam doing a bit of yoga at home only.Once it gets better I´ ll look for some classes too.Even I wish to join some dance class but I have developed chronic bronchitis and asthma thanks to the stress I undertook the small cold and coughs got aggravated resulting in this permanent problem.This is the reason why Iam doing pranayam I´ ve heard that it cures asthma too.Regarding my SIL knowing me join the yoga classes she followed me one day ,the receptionist told me that a female had come and she was inquiring about you.(timings etc)It was easy for her to keep my track because they have no other work.If I take my daughter to taekwondo classes she will get her son there too,whatever I do they end up landing there if I leave it they also leave that activity.My MIL is enough to put ghee in fire.One day my daughters guitar sir had come my dear MIL met him on the way and asked Kaun ho kiske liye aye ho? Next week there was a casio sir upstairs too.(COPY CATS)They do such things to constantly irritate me.You are absolutely right They can never never be good to me.Thanks to you again for releiving my stress with your replies.
2008-01-24
#7
Name: Ritika Subject: Re
Dear Geeta,
Your MIL and SIL love to make you miserable, don' t they. Seems as if they love to pick up a fight and then they get to shout and scream and feel wonderful about it.
How are you coping on the husband front? Are you still doing a lot of household work? Or are you getting some rest??
The thing is there is very little you can change about your MIL or SIL. I don' t know why they are behaving this way and I don' t care. What I do care about is for you not to get so upset over them.
Knowing yr SIL' s nature - that she gets upset if someone intrudes her space (she might be considering the entire 2nd flr as her personal space and did not like a servant coming up without her permission...I don' t know..am guessing here..), I would seriously not interact with her much. Send yr servant up when your husband is present in the house (so he can hear what is happening).
I don' t think there is any law about 2nd flr people owning the terrace specially since its supposed to be one house and one family.
Have you thought about moving out from this atmosphere? Frankly I do not see one positive thing for you to stay there. Your kid is not looked after by yr MIL. She goes to day care. In fact she hears you get abused by her grandmom. She sees her mother getting depressed...it must be really hard for her...
Can you talk to your husband about living separately? When there are too many vessels in a basket, there is bound to be noise. If there were few vessels, there wouldn' t be so much of drama and tension.
Lastly, try not to think about stuff like who drew on the walls or who threw things on the balcony. Focus on the bigger issues - like did I smile today, did I have a nice conversation with my hubby, did I work on my hobby today...etc etc.
As for all the stuff that gets thrown on yr balcony, just quietly go and pick it up and put it in a box in yr room. Then donate it to charity if the claimants do not apologize and claim it in 2 weeks. As for your MIL. Just stop talking to her. There is no need for you to listen to her abuse. When she starts abusing, tell her to mind her language and then walk away.
Also, plan more outings with your husband...go out on vacation more often..in fact do it every weekend so that you don' t spend it at home with yr MIL and SIL.
take care...
2008-01-25
#8
Name: Geeta Subject: update
Well Ritika the entire house is in my MIL´ s name and when both the brothers were young she took their signatures that they are not a part of it only she will own it.Now I dont know whether it would be valid or not.Rgarding talking to his brother my dear MIL has created so much differences in the family that even the brothers dont talk.As it is he only listens to his wife or her brother.That matter is also closed for us.Nowadays she (MIL) has started telling everyone that she is very sick etc. etc and she wants herslf to be trated by agood doctor but the fact is taht everytime I took her she absolutely had no problem at all.Even her tests revealed and the doctors said she is perfectly alright.She just wants me to be her personal driver taking her to her friends place,shopping,kitty parties and to spend money in doctors for no reason.She would build castles in air,talk all lies which is really unbelievable for a person to do this at her age.obviously she wouldnt say anything to my dominating SIL.She would call her name and say bechari.... she has to do so much.Anyway,If I start decribing things she does it would take days to write.I dont know its my illluck to be trapped in such a situation.Ritika I started going to yoga classes,it was just 15 days when my SIL´ s daughter also landed in the same place.Now I dont feel like going ther because I will not be at peace if I see their face.Doing yoga at home Iam not very regular.I somehow feel nice that atleast there is someone who is taking time to read my problems it helps definately.Thanks Ritika waiting for your reply.
2008-01-24
#9
Name: Ritika Subject: Re:
Dear Geeta,
I´ m so glad that you are slowly pulling yourself out of doing all the household work and getting some time for yourself...Meditation is great...if you can then try yoga also...that will also help...
About the property, can you lock your rooms and live separately? Or can your husband ask his brother if he wants to buy his share in the house?
I know people in my family as well as my husband´ s where all the brothers do not live live together (live in different cities because of their jobs) but keep their rooms locked up in the ancestral house/joint family house so as not to lose their share of the property.
The house is in whose name btw?
But hey, you are doing the right thing by focusing on yourself...spend more quality time with your hubby and kid..make yr times together fun and enjoyable...
The weather must be good in India right now...pack a basket of food on Saturday and go for a picnic to some near by spot..
Whenever I have a tough week at work or home, that is what I do..my hubby and I go for a long drive with our baby...have lunch somewhere and generally just chit chat...helps a lot in relieving tension...
Take care...
love,
Ritika
2008-01-24
#10
Name: Geeta Subject: my position now.
Thanks Ritika.Reading your posts are like rejuvenator to me.I know I cannot do anything about my MIL or SIL.Regarding moving out of this place will be losing on the property that is the partFloor) which we constructed on our hard earned money.They are bound to grab it the moment we vacate.At least even my husband fears it.Would it be practical to do so I dont know.Not for me but nothing would be left for my daughter too,though sometimes I feel to hell with the property but again the insecurity comes.Regarding doing all the household job Iam slowly pulling myself out of it.I also try to do meditation for a short while.I hope it will help me in long run to deal with such people.Thanks again..
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic : waiting for ur reply Ritika and Srey
Subscribe to this conversation!
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic : waiting for ur reply Ritika and Srey
Subscribe to this conversation!
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic : waiting for ur reply Ritika and Srey
Don't think too much .its common Nowdays... - Deepika [View Message]
RE:RE:sex in joint family
Wish to know one real person... - Dippy [View Message]
Arrangement with inlaws
Hi Everyone,
I am about to get married soon and I want suggestion regarding a certain living arrangement that me, my to be husband and in-laws are thinking about to maintain peace as well as be available for each other.
We are confused as to if we should live in the same house and different floors or we should stay in separate apartments in the same apartment s... - Anupama Singhal [View Message]
RE:RE:sex in joint family
One should take care. It's private. ... - Dippy [View Message]
Should a single man live with his mum in India?
I am a man in my late 40s and I have lived abroad in USA for the past two decades. I never had any interest in marrying or having kids so I never married. Recently my Dad passed away and my mother will be alone. I have made enough money to retire comfortably but because I am used to the American lifestyle I can't live in India. Recently my relatives have started saying tha... - Venkat Dabri [View Message]
RE:sex in joint family
It's very common in joint family.just ignore... - Minal [View Message]
I am Newhere
Hi all , I am newbie to this forum...hope you all feel well... - Lucamia Ava [View Message]