You are here: Home > Message Boards > Relationships >  Joint Family >..urgent ritika..n others...need help

Relationships  Discussion Forum

 
Joint Family:..urgent ritika..n others...need help
2007-12-05
Name: gg



u will be shocked to hear this..
u knwo all this while i was away from board i was in problem...u can say shocked...
u hv heard always abotu my sil...how we get along with wach other n all...
u know on friday..evenig..my sil called me...i am telling u all exact conversation btwn me n her...
she called up to tell me that she n her husband had gone to see some property n it seems they liked one...she said :
my husband liked one flat it is 1bhk...n 600 sqft (this words of her pinched me) i said but 600 sqft flat will be enough for all of us?
she said: y not in bedroom we both will sleep and in hall erst all will manage..(mark her sentence there is no mention of me n my husband..still i asked her what about us? )
she said: i am telling u this is the only golden oppurtunity for u n ur husband to stay back..when we are about to leave u n ur husband say that sorry we are not coming with u ..n we want to stay here ..(which is a house on rent) as we cant live in hall...
by this time i was completely cold n my bp shot up..still i ddnt lose my temper n asked her ..what about kitchen ? cant we convert the kitchen n bedroom for us n a small kitchen in hall ...she said: ccccchhhhhheeeeee that will spoil my houses interior ...its better u stay here...
i was shocked....
i told my husband all this ...luckily he was free ..weekend...
he said let er talk whatever she wants to talk .....let her say whatever she wants to say...u keep ur mouth shut..coz first of all they cant afford a house ..max earning is of my husbands...which too goes staringht in my mils hands...
he is saying she must hv inquired about some house...n loan..n some marketing fellow must hv showd her stars..n she is talking non sense...
n i know my huband n his bro..all are mama' s boys...thye will never leave her..nor my mil will never let them seperate...my mil is very very storn g... u dont knwo her..she always tell s her 4 sons not to leave each other no matter what..?
its jsut impossible..my mil very very smart ...first of al she wont go with her ...then she cant lwave me...
another ..she wont let any 1 son of her live seprate from her...thats impossible...

i am not about scared of my sil' s plans..or insecrure ...coz i know it wont happen..
but look at my sil?
i am the one who saved her couple of times from her husband..whn the entier family ddtn even bother to stop the fight ...n helped her so much ...whn she was unwell i did wall the work without any complkain...
she turned out to be so mean? i am shocked...
i hv lwarnt one thing from this..at ur in laws there is no one of urs...
any comments....
n see her brain she wants me to break the family...so that entire blame comes on my head that i was the one to break the family not her...
n do u think she will keep every1 with her no way....impossible...she has told me this many times b4...
any comments
Subscribe to this conversation Reply Anonymously

 

2007-12-05
#1
Anonymous Name: Ritika
Subject:  Re:



Hi gg,

I can see that you are very upset...but I' m a bit confused about the reason.

Is it because your SIL wants to stay separately? Or is it because she expects you and your hubby to pitch in to pay for her house?

She might not be happy in a joint family and with a baby on the way, it will be very crowded in your house.

You yourself told us that she had told you earlier that she wants to move out...

Unless your SIL or BIL is expecting any money from you for their house, I honestly don' t see why you are so angry with them...

You can' t (and should not) force others to live and suffer in that household if they are not happy.

As for your MIL, I told you in my last message, her dream of 15+ people always staying together is never going to materialize. Sooner or later, people WILL break free from her yoke.

She might want to control others, but others might not want to be controlled forever.

It is HER idea that ALL of you should stay together. Isnt it?? So why perpetuate it..let HER do the talking or pushing.

Why are YOU fighting for her?? If she has a problem, she' ll come out with it. Let your MIL and SIL fight this one out. Don' t get into this. You' ll needlessly spoil yr relationship with yr SIL and BIL.

Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top

 
2007-12-06
#2
Anonymous Name: gg
Subject:  hi....ritika.............



i think by now u know my prob very well...my mil wish is to stay in a joint family ....we dont hv any prob..only thing is space ...that too is not an issue till my other 2 bil decides to get mrrd which will happen in a yera or 2...n the palce we stay is a rented one...not our own...we hv money we can afford a house but max 1bhk...which will atleast cost us 20 to 25 lacs...little loan if we apply for it is possible ...that too is not an issue we can cleasr that loan within 5 or max 8 years...
but if we go acc to my mil we hv to buy 4bhk...each bro gets 1 bdrm..n in the hall or kithcne my mil n sil will manage...anyways one day my sil will get mrrd...
my mils...plan is right now 3 bros are working...ok...max earning is of my dh n i hv one more bil..who is studing ..she is banking on him..coz he will make a very good career..if he gets a good job i am sure he will be the maxi eaning mebr of the fmaily...
this 4 bhk will cost us atleast 50 to 60 lacs...which is a huge amount for us..her plan is that either my husband or my elder bil should take a loan ..n with the help of 4 earning s she is run the house n clear the loan too...eg..2 bro´ s earning will go in clearing loan ..n other 2 will run the house...
if we do this al lthe earning will go in clearing loan n hosue expenses what abotu saiving ? what about childrens future n marriage? n clearing that 50 ..60 lacs will take comlete 20 years....byt eh time we clear that loan we will be 50 years old....all the life i will be earning if i hv to think about my childrens futer..
i still dont wnat to seperate ..i can manage joint family...n i love ...as i hv always said...it has pros n cons but nuclear family too hv...
i hv no prob with nay other member of the famliy...my mil had told my sill all this b4 mrrg..but from the day she got mrrd her biggest dream is to stay seprate..she herself has told htis to my mil several fights....in front of every1...she said she doesnt want any1 from the famlily...
now all of a sudden my sil came with this idea...of leaving us behind shocked me..i was taken aback..
my sil wont take any financila help from any1 ..any bros coz she says if i take help from them 2mrw they may clami share in my house...which is not an issue at all...
i am too consufese as to y she said all this to me? is she trying to read my mind?
worst come to worst even if they go ..its a good thing for me..i am not in loss....i can def manage...
there is some kind of khichdi cooking in her mind...i will gv u in writing that she wont take the entire family with her ..no way...she is not the one who can live in joint family..she is too independent...she hates cooking ...if u tell her to boil water she wont do it...she will make face...u can see her from her face how all the time she is irritated in our presense...
anyways last night i had a talk with my husband ..i told him..for 2 years wihtout any compalin i took all the harassment ...torture of ur mother..i never comlained..about a single thing to u or to any1...i did my best to keep ur family 2gether...if they leave me 2mrw alone...it will hurt me very badly...when they were in need of house for my bil...when he got mrrd they came to us..now whn they hv a house they are leaving us in this rented house all alone...2mrw my sil harasses yr mother (which she will purposely do it ....so that they run away...) n u tell me to take ur mother back ...my doors are closed for her 4ever....u hv to choose tbwn ur mother n wife...my dh was shocked ...he is still in shokc about what i said...i dont htink ia m wrong...enough of kicks ...now its my time ....
i think my sil has come up with a new idea...she wants me to say no ...that i wont go n live with my sil....by doing this my mil will get hurt ..n all out community will say see this girl ddnt wanted to stay in joint family...n after taking all of them she will harass wver1 so much ...that my mil ..n fil...they all hv huge ego probs they will leave her house on their own..agian community wil say my in laws left the hosue on theri own..
this way her name wont get spoiled ...
i think her mind is working too much..
i am upset about what she said n the she said...it made very cleasr that she doenst want me...it doesnt make any diff..but it hurt me..coz i supported her a lot..at home...

ur are absolutely ...now onwards i wont interfere with her...at all....i hv got a reason now..she will obviously realise this...that i felt bad..
Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2007-12-05
#3
Anonymous Name: gg
Subject:  same here



i too was feeling low all this while coz my sil was the only one who brought change in my life...i am ok now...i just wanted to tell all of u about his...i was just waiting to come back to normal...my friend had told me once that be ware of this babe..coz in her life it was her elder sil who had made their life miserable...
let her pin up hopes....i hv decided one thing i will keep my mouth shut n behave normally with her..jsut as u said ..she is thinking that she is smarter than all...let her be under that impression..there is one dirty saying...cunning crow at the end of the day ends up sitting on s**t without realising what he is sitting on....i know one thing ...my god is there with me....whne mrrd...i went thru all this i never thought my sil will come n change things for me...same way u never know what will happen 2mrw..let us keep our heart n mind clean thats it ..u can survive in this world alone..not a big deal...lets see in store fir me..!anyways u all are there to share my probs...
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top
 

2007-12-05
#4
Anonymous Name: Dd
Subject:  hi gg



Hi,

I myself is feeling very low today so i didnot replied to u an hour back when i read it. Now i will be leaving for a meeting in half an hour so thought to write to u.
I was also wondering since 2-3 days about your absence was waiting for u since morning.
As for your sil' s behaviuor i am not very surprised a s i have seen many people like that. Many times on this massage board also such charecters have appeared. I know it hurts bcs you do so much for them & they behave with u badly. But as many of our friend on this board has said before don' t expect anything from il' s,sil' s, co-sil' s etc. that is the only advice i ahve for u. and also stop doing tthings for them or going overboard in your relations with them. I have similar relations with my co-sil(devrani). I don' t neglect her but i talk to her occasionally & gift her things once or twice in year like diwali & sometimes on birthday or aniversary. let her buy 1 bhk if she can & go there to stay alone bcs that will open doors for u also to find your own place.
also why u r worried about she will make u scapegoat? bcs u also know that your mil will never move in with her even if she manages to convince her husband to buy the place. as with her your mil will ahve to do the work & also it will be her house so she will dominate them & your mil will never except that.
So instead of getting hurt. be happy about it & also show to her that u r happy for her. that way she will get the massage that she can not hurt u.
take care.
love
Dd
Reply to Original MessageReply to Original Message   Reply to Original Message Reply to This Message   Msg Objection   Go to Top

All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
..urgent ritika..n others...need help


Subscribe to this conversation! All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
..urgent ritika..n others...need help


Subscribe to this conversation! All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic :
..urgent ritika..n others...need help

Thanks for subscribing
You are already a member, please login to subscribe

------ OR ------

Expecting Parents
Parents of Babies
Last 7 Posts of this Board
RE:sex in joint family
Don't think too much .its common Nowdays... - Deepika [View Message]
RE:RE:sex in joint family
Wish to know one real person... - Dippy [View Message]
Arrangement with inlaws
Hi Everyone,
I am about to get married soon and I want suggestion regarding a certain living arrangement that me, my to be husband and in-laws are thinking about to maintain peace as well as be available for each other.
We are confused as to if we should live in the same house and different floors or we should stay in separate apartments in the same apartment s... - Anupama Singhal [View Message]
RE:RE:sex in joint family
One should take care. It's private. ... - Dippy [View Message]
Should a single man live with his mum in India?
I am a man in my late 40s and I have lived abroad in USA for the past two decades. I never had any interest in marrying or having kids so I never married. Recently my Dad passed away and my mother will be alone. I have made enough money to retire comfortably but because I am used to the American lifestyle I can't live in India. Recently my relatives have started saying tha... - Venkat Dabri [View Message]
RE:sex in joint family
It's very common in joint family.just ignore... - Minal [View Message]
I am Newhere
Hi all , I am newbie to this forum...hope you all feel well... - Lucamia Ava [View Message]