i new to this site n really need friend's shoulders to lean in . a slight introduction from my side.m married to my childhood darling from 4 yrs. marriage annoucement was horrible from both the side which lead to seperation of ours for 2 yrs.after 2 yrs by hook n crook we got married.my parents accepted us from the day we got married but from my husband side nobody accepted till next 2 yrs.we got settled in differnt country so wasnt problem.it took time to get settle from his side.
now after 4 yrs of our marriage my brother in law means my husband bro also got married without annoucing anything n brought his bride home and my MIL accepted her as she is.n she wanted to have a grand reception of it and wanted us to attend it also.
we are so upset that how come a mother be so partial to her sons.my husband is such a good son.only our marriage is the only thing he did opposite of them or else he listen to each n everything of them.despite of this his younger bro is black sheep of his family then also his family is behaving so nicely n cooly with him.the new bride is also from a bad uncultered family still everything is ok for them.
i m wondering how come a mother think good for 1 n bad for other son.we had never done false in our whole life but after hearing such things in our life ,life goes so in misery.
My husband is having a such a heartbreak i can really cant see it.he is a perfect son,husband and father.but still he is not getting enough or good status in his family.mean while in my family inspite of ours love marriage my dad take or ask his suggestion in big occasion as good soninlaw.
i dont know y such things happen to good people n how come such people dont have hearts.
sorry if i make u feel bore but i was really feeling too bad n was feeling to talk to someone .
sonu
Subscribe to this conversation
Reply Anonymously
hi friends,
i new to this site n really need friend's shoulders to lean in . a slight introduction from my side.m married to my childhood darling from 4 yrs. marriage annoucement was horrible from both the side which lead to seperation of ours for 2 yrs.after 2 yrs by hook n crook we got married.my parents accepted us from the day we got married but from my husband side nobody accepted till next 2 yrs.we got settled in differnt country so wasnt problem.it took time to get settle from his side.
now after 4 yrs of our marriage my brother in law means my husband bro also got married without annoucing anything n brought his bride home and my MIL accepted her as she is.n she wanted to have a grand reception of it and wanted us to attend it also.
we are so upset that how come a mother be so partial to her sons.my husband is such a good son.only our marriage is the only thing he did opposite of them or else he listen to each n everything of them.despite of this his younger bro is black sheep of his family then also his family is behaving so nicely n cooly with him.the new bride is also from a bad uncultered family still everything is ok for them.
i m wondering how come a mother think good for 1 n bad for other son.we had never done false in our whole life but after hearing such things in our life ,life goes so in misery.
My husband is having a such a heartbreak i can really cant see it.he is a perfect son,husband and father.but still he is not getting enough or good status in his family.mean while in my family inspite of ours love marriage my dad take or ask his suggestion in big occasion as good soninlaw.
i dont know y such things happen to good people n how come such people dont have hearts.
sorry if i make u feel bore but i was really feeling too bad n was feeling to talk to someone .
sonu
JointFamily replied. Hi, everyone has given some friendly advise. Here is some techy analysis! Don't feel bad, you are a good person. I may sound partial but I am being honest in my thoughts.
a. You need someone's shoulder to lean.
Are you trying to get some sympathy? Come on, you are already strong person.
b. His parents did not accept for 2 years.
Their heart is broken that such a good son that they brought up went against their wishes. Bridge is broken. Only way is you both stop thinking negative about them.
c. BIL reception.
Parents fulfilling unfulfilled desire through other son. MIL wanting you to attend to \";show-off\"; as natural human jealousy. Why worry of materialistic pleasures?
d. Your hubby only opposed for marriage.
It is ultimate dream shattered for parents. Most parents think marraige is a point where son changes his attitude or behaviour towards them. So previous good work is not valued much.
e. BIL black sheep, new bride uncultured.
No comments. You are accusing without much facts, I believe.
f. MIL partial.
If you get teased, people tease you. When she behaves like this, it must be reflecting on your face! So she enjoys doing that.
g. Hubby's status.
Dad/mum must be going through heartburn everyday. They won't forgive him easily. It is FIL's duty to respect good SIL. So no credit.
h. Unknowns.
We reflect on things unknowingly when we behave. Those don't go unnoticed though. Some pains are hard to forget and forgive. But can be heeled with respect and positive thinking.
i. Suggestion.
Stop thinking and expecting normal treatment from FIL and MIL. Don't even keep heart burn and pain in your souls. Become polite in tone. Be firm to state what you like what you don't.
Start respecting your relatives. God forbid, if something wrong happens to you or your kids, believe me, your parents and his parents will be the first one to feel the pain in the whole world. BIL and SIL will come running with help.
shaily replied. Hello sonu,
I completely understand how you are feeling. My situation is not the same as you.. but in our case my co-sis is not working and so she bad mouths about me to my MIL to the extent that my MIL has started thinking that all working girls are hopeless.. She even treated my child very badly because of which we had to move out and now we are the bad people.. my BIL is in a govt service and has not even completed his graduation and me and my husband are s/w engrs.. so you can well understand the pressure on usto support their family and in return hear bad things about us..
But, now we live separately and i dont give a damn about what they think about me and how my MIL treats my co-sis and all... because it is very hard to change the thinking with which these people have been brought up and it will only cause us pain.. although i know that whenever you remember those things youcant help but feel sooooo bad. i hope it makes you feel better to know that you are not alone in such a situation..
take care
replied. Hey how is ur mil treating u people now. Maybe in the beginning she could not accept the marriage. but by this time she would have changed. And thats why she wants to accept her second dil. Go and enjoy the reception. Be diplomatic. Anyways u people don't stay with them right. So make the new bride feel at home. By seeing ur good nature ur mil might feel ashamed of not accepting u people in the beginning. Just give a try. If she still does not accept, then fine, just come back. Thats all.
A Lady replied. Where are you at? If you live in America, maybe we can talk on the phone and be friends. My story is similar but not the same like yours. We also got married without his family's approval but my family accepted us 100%. His family is not the same with us and we have been together for a long time. I worry about his brother marrying too and know his mother will treat his wife so differently. It hasn't happened yet but I don't want to be a part of it even when it happens. It hurts too much because we had no reception. It hurts but can we do? Just accept it. Too bad it makes our life miserable though.
If you want to be phone friends let me know. I live in the USA. Where are you?
leaf replied. hi sonu,
this is a golden chance for u. see, most indian men cannot seem to find faults with their parents, and even if they r given proof, then they r very reluctant to accept that their parents r bad. so even if their wife (DIL) is sufferring, they will do nothing to break the relation or separate.
now in ur case, ur husband is right now feeling bad because of his mom/s behaviour. what u must do is instead of telling him not to feel bad, tell him it is very bad and all. ie. put more poison in his head. but do it very diplomatically. ie he should not feel that u r purposely poisoning him. say things like 'what wrong have we done? why is god punishing us this way?' and 'afterall we cannot do anything. if it is in our kismat to not get accepted by the family then what can we do?'. or say that 'because of me, ur mother has drifted fom u'
and dont eat for some days (just act, u can eat when he's not there)so he should feel that u r feeling very bad and neglected and all.
this is thr right time to kulhadi maro. he must feel that only u love him. and so u will not have probs later on in life like when u ask for his support and he supports his mom instead!!
kruti replied. may be the first episode of ur marriage put some sens in them. fearing they might also go awya and setlle somewhere she agreed immly.
2005-12-02
#1
Name: JointFamily Subject: I don't see respect in your write-up!
Hi, everyone has given some friendly advise. Here is some techy analysis! Don't feel bad, you are a good person. I may sound partial but I am being honest in my thoughts.
a. You need someone's shoulder to lean.
Are you trying to get some sympathy? Come on, you are already strong person.
b. His parents did not accept for 2 years.
Their heart is broken that such a good son that they brought up went against their wishes. Bridge is broken. Only way is you both stop thinking negative about them.
c. BIL reception.
Parents fulfilling unfulfilled desire through other son. MIL wanting you to attend to \";show-off\"; as natural human jealousy. Why worry of materialistic pleasures?
d. Your hubby only opposed for marriage.
It is ultimate dream shattered for parents. Most parents think marraige is a point where son changes his attitude or behaviour towards them. So previous good work is not valued much.
e. BIL black sheep, new bride uncultured.
No comments. You are accusing without much facts, I believe.
f. MIL partial.
If you get teased, people tease you. When she behaves like this, it must be reflecting on your face! So she enjoys doing that.
g. Hubby's status.
Dad/mum must be going through heartburn everyday. They won't forgive him easily. It is FIL's duty to respect good SIL. So no credit.
h. Unknowns.
We reflect on things unknowingly when we behave. Those don't go unnoticed though. Some pains are hard to forget and forgive. But can be heeled with respect and positive thinking.
i. Suggestion.
Stop thinking and expecting normal treatment from FIL and MIL. Don't even keep heart burn and pain in your souls. Become polite in tone. Be firm to state what you like what you don't.
Start respecting your relatives. God forbid, if something wrong happens to you or your kids, believe me, your parents and his parents will be the first one to feel the pain in the whole world. BIL and SIL will come running with help.
2005-12-06
#2
Name: JointFamily Subject: You choose
Hey Sonu, You obviously have more context and my advise is based on brief text you posted. So you choose what is right and wrong. But I don't give up easily!
Parents are not perfect, I agree. They make mistakes.
b. Wrong on mummy's part to say that to son, assuming your hubby understood her correctly.
c. Who cares on what people say when one is beyond pleasures of false respect?
f. I didn't say you teased, I said you get teased, so fun for her. Also, who told you to book flat in her name? What if hubby expires? Who will look after you and kids? Hubby must buy property in wife and kids names, though if he has extra money, can always deposit on parent's names.
She will take things for granted. Her property can be claimed by BIL in future.
Not a queston of forgiving, but being unbiased and reasonable.
Good luck.
2005-12-06
#3
Name: sonu Subject: i think its mitra
hi ,
i think its mitra who posted this msgs here.u r not wrong partially but half things how u stated is not like it is.
b.u said bridge is broken.but there was no bridge indeed.i ask u who mother whn her son is just 12 yrs old studying in school says him to earn money n eat dont eat like beggars.only bcz she played for half n hours more.it was not only once but in that half n hours both brothers played n mom scolded only 1.
c.u said y b so materialistic.ours were love marriage and hsi brothers also.this sunday the reception took place.MIl said to all of guests that it was arrange marriage though from girls side no 1 came as no 1 accepted their daughters as well as SIL.all made fun of us.
f.u said i teased her so she is teasing me now,but she is harming her own status.we book our 1st flat in her name.n his bro took flat he took in his wife's name.whose fault.
g.agreed with ur comment.
so on i agree with u but few things are not misguided my dear.mothers can also do wrong.they are not always perfect.
but i agree to forgive
sonu
2005-11-14
#4
Name: shaily Subject: I understand
Hello sonu,
I completely understand how you are feeling. My situation is not the same as you.. but in our case my co-sis is not working and so she bad mouths about me to my MIL to the extent that my MIL has started thinking that all working girls are hopeless.. She even treated my child very badly because of which we had to move out and now we are the bad people.. my BIL is in a govt service and has not even completed his graduation and me and my husband are s/w engrs.. so you can well understand the pressure on usto support their family and in return hear bad things about us..
But, now we live separately and i dont give a damn about what they think about me and how my MIL treats my co-sis and all... because it is very hard to change the thinking with which these people have been brought up and it will only cause us pain.. although i know that whenever you remember those things youcant help but feel sooooo bad. i hope it makes you feel better to know that you are not alone in such a situation..
take care
2005-11-15
#5
Name: sonu Subject: everyone faces same problem
hi shaily,
ya i can understand everything u r facing.sometimes its really feel out of reach.we cant do anything.atleast we feel good that ours husband understands us fully.by thinking that only we should feel better.
take care
sonu
2005-11-14
#6
Name: Subject: could be
Hey how is ur mil treating u people now. Maybe in the beginning she could not accept the marriage. but by this time she would have changed. And thats why she wants to accept her second dil. Go and enjoy the reception. Be diplomatic. Anyways u people don't stay with them right. So make the new bride feel at home. By seeing ur good nature ur mil might feel ashamed of not accepting u people in the beginning. Just give a try. If she still does not accept, then fine, just come back. Thats all.
2005-11-14
#7
Name: sonu Subject: may be
hi,
it could be as u r saying but they r calling us for to bear expenses.i know my MIL is not at all change towards us.this year itself we had to go to India for 1 month because my mom passed away so goin again now is impossible.money wise as well as holidays wise.
she just dont have heart at all towards us.I gave birth to my baby last year May by caseraion My MIL was knowing i will deliver till May or june but she went to US to stay with her brother n came back after my delivery . Now my BIL is working abroad too but his family is not allowed there,so he will keep his wife with my MIL.just imagine when mIL saw my Baby first time she dint even took her in her arms now she is so good to that other girl.even now also my baby is 18 mths she dint took her in arms nor gave any present nor hugged her.
what kind of behaviour is this? we are ready to keep her with us but she dont want to stay with us and her other son dont want to stay with her.after he comes from abroad he will stay separate in his own flat.
thanks for ur suggestions n reading my life story.
sonu
2005-11-13
#8
Name: A Lady Subject: I know how you feel.
Where are you at? If you live in America, maybe we can talk on the phone and be friends. My story is similar but not the same like yours. We also got married without his family's approval but my family accepted us 100%. His family is not the same with us and we have been together for a long time. I worry about his brother marrying too and know his mother will treat his wife so differently. It hasn't happened yet but I don't want to be a part of it even when it happens. It hurts too much because we had no reception. It hurts but can we do? Just accept it. Too bad it makes our life miserable though.
If you want to be phone friends let me know. I live in the USA. Where are you?
2005-11-11
#9
Name: leaf Subject: ur chance
hi sonu,
this is a golden chance for u. see, most indian men cannot seem to find faults with their parents, and even if they r given proof, then they r very reluctant to accept that their parents r bad. so even if their wife (DIL) is sufferring, they will do nothing to break the relation or separate.
now in ur case, ur husband is right now feeling bad because of his mom/s behaviour. what u must do is instead of telling him not to feel bad, tell him it is very bad and all. ie. put more poison in his head. but do it very diplomatically. ie he should not feel that u r purposely poisoning him. say things like 'what wrong have we done? why is god punishing us this way?' and 'afterall we cannot do anything. if it is in our kismat to not get accepted by the family then what can we do?'. or say that 'because of me, ur mother has drifted fom u'
and dont eat for some days (just act, u can eat when he's not there)so he should feel that u r feeling very bad and neglected and all.
this is thr right time to kulhadi maro. he must feel that only u love him. and so u will not have probs later on in life like when u ask for his support and he supports his mom instead!!
2005-11-11
#10
Name: kruti Subject: reply
may be the first episode of ur marriage put some sens in them. fearing they might also go awya and setlle somewhere she agreed immly.
2005-11-11
#11
Name: sonu Subject: not so
hi,
its not so kruti my husband is working from 6 yrs abroad.n youngr 1 also works in nigeria now he will be leaving his bride with my MIL.
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic : feel to bad friends
Subscribe to this conversation!
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
& Answers to Topic : feel to bad friends
Subscribe to this conversation!
All tips on Relationships
You ever wanted in one place.
No need to go anywhere else.
Don't think too much .its common Nowdays... - Deepika [View Message]
RE:RE:sex in joint family
Wish to know one real person... - Dippy [View Message]
Arrangement with inlaws
Hi Everyone,
I am about to get married soon and I want suggestion regarding a certain living arrangement that me, my to be husband and in-laws are thinking about to maintain peace as well as be available for each other.
We are confused as to if we should live in the same house and different floors or we should stay in separate apartments in the same apartment s... - Anupama Singhal [View Message]
RE:RE:sex in joint family
One should take care. It's private. ... - Dippy [View Message]
Should a single man live with his mum in India?
I am a man in my late 40s and I have lived abroad in USA for the past two decades. I never had any interest in marrying or having kids so I never married. Recently my Dad passed away and my mother will be alone. I have made enough money to retire comfortably but because I am used to the American lifestyle I can't live in India. Recently my relatives have started saying tha... - Venkat Dabri [View Message]
RE:sex in joint family
It's very common in joint family.just ignore... - Minal [View Message]
I am Newhere
Hi all , I am newbie to this forum...hope you all feel well... - Lucamia Ava [View Message]